We were really impressed with Piperlime’s fresh, modern site design and long list of popular brand names to choose from. And we definitely enjoyed browsing the shoes at Piperlime, which included a wide range of styles for men, women, and children. The women’s handbags were also a unique and interesting site department.

• Free shipping on all orders.
• Regular sweepstakes for winning free shoes and trips.

We did think that Piperlime has a somewhat limited selection when it comes to running and athletic shoes, but they definitely have fashion covered. Add that to the fact that their customer service is second to none and it's not hard to see why so many demanding fashion divas love the store.

Overall, Piperlime offers fashionable shoes at standard prices. The upside to shopping with the company is that it provides free shipping and returns, as well as a variety of sale products and style headline articles. If you're into fashion and demand the best when it comes to customer support, Piperlime is definitely a site to check out. StarReviews gives Piperlime 5.5 Stars!

Payless ShoeSource proved to be one of our favorite online shoe stores. We already loved their low prices, and the online BOGO sale just made the deals sweeter.  With the BOGO sales, for each pair of shoes you buy, you get a second for half price. Payless, while not always prestigious, is definitely affordable.

• Have orders shipped to any of the store’s 4,600 nationwide locations for free.
• BOGO sales allow you to buy one pair or shoes and get the second half off.

Speaking of prestigious – you will have to give up many popular name brands if you want to take advantage of the site's deals. While they do offer a few popular names such as Champion and American Eagle, you're not going to find Nike or Adidas, and you sure as heck won't find Chanel or Dior.

That being said, if you don't mind sacrificing a name on a label for some seriously awesome deals, Payless ShoeSource's online store is definitely a site you're going to want to check out. Payless ShoeSource gets 5.0 Stars!

DSW did a great job of drawing us in to their website with a homepage that was packed with colorful icons and special deals. Once we were inside the site we were happy to see that there was a wide selection of men's and women's shoes to choose from, offered at reasonable prices for every budget. That being said, no children's shoes are offered, which might be a downer for some shoppers.

• Free shipping all orders for DSW Rewards members.
• Listings of popular trends and hot sellers.

If you need men's or women's shoes and you appreciate quality, fashion and high-end brands at a discount, check out the clearance section of the site. We found it to offer high-quality shoes at dramatically reduced prices.

The only thing that we didn’t like about DSW is that it seems to focus more on trends and fashion than meeting the basic needs of its customers. Sections such as the Style Spotlight and Hot Sellers list are interesting, but some shoppers might prefer to see more options such as children’s shoes and accessories available. If, however, if you’re looking for an easy way to stay connected to current shoe trends, DSW is your place.  They earned 4.5 Stars!

Although the ShoeMall website is laid out a bit awkwardly, it provides an overall-pleasant shopping experience, especially if you wear a shoe size that is hard to shop for. There are plenty of brands and styles to choose from in a variety of sizes and widths. Even if your width is EEEEEE, ShoeMall.com has you covered.

• Free shipping on all orders.
• “Bend Over Backwards” satisfaction guarantee.

We think that ShoeMall’s prices are pretty competitive, especially when taken into consideration with the 110% Price Guarantee and “Bend Over Backwards” Satisfaction Guarantee. At the time of our visit, there was a sale going on offering a set dollar amount off of tiered price purchases, and the Sale section of the website also provides a number of discounted shoes prices year-round. Add that to free shipping and while the site's regular prices may seem a bit high, the promotions make up for it.

The only thing we didn’t like about ShoeMall is that it doesn’t offer any children’s shoes. That being said, they do offer live customer support 7 days a week, and seem to go out of their way to make sure that their customers are happy and satisfied. Overall, ShoeMall definitely gets our recommendation as a store worthy of serving your footwear needs. StarReviews awards ShoeMall 4.5 Stars!